Real Estate QA Can I Get My Neighbor To Pay For Her Trees Damage To My House

Dated: 04/18/2018

Views: 7

Real Estate Q&A: Can I Get My Neighbor to Pay for Her Tree’s Damage to My House?


(TNS)—Q: My neighbor’s large, seemingly dead tree overhangs my screened-in pool and has long made me nervous. I have repeatedly asked her to remove it. She always ignored or rejected my requests. During a hurricane, the tree finally came down, like I knew it would, and damaged my pool cage and house. The damage, while expensive, was less than my insurance deductible. Can I get my neighbor to pay for the damage?

A: The rules regarding neighbors’ trees that overhang or intrude on your property are long settled and have been discussed in this space before: If a branch or root extends on your property, you may trim the tree back to the property line but may not kill or unnecessarily damage the tree. If you do not take the opportunity to do this, and your property is damaged as a result, you would bear the repair costs.

The concept is, simply stated, that it is better to let you protect your own property in a reasonable way, then subject your neighbors to the burden—and the public to the numerous lawsuits that would ensue if the rule were any different.

However, your situation was not typical since the tree may have been dead and you had repeatedly warned your neighbor of the problem it could cause. In determining whether you can seek reimbursement from your neighbor, the health of the fallen tree should be considered. If the tree was dead, and your neighbor knew it could cause a problem, she can be held responsible for the repairs in court.

Generally speaking, when a neighbor’s living tree falls on your house, you need to make your own repairs—but if the tree is dead, then your neighbor is on the hook.

Courtesy of RIS Media, written by Gary M. Singer is a Florida attorney and board-certified as an expert in real estate law by the Florida Bar.

Blog author image

Ron Haibi

With over 12 years in the Real Estate Business, I have personally sold hundreds of homes such as resales, foreclosures and REO’s. As the owner and active broker, I hold many designations to better s....

Latest Blog Posts

White And Grey Kitchens Dallas Style

Photo courtesy of Charlotte Comer Interiors, Inc. Interior design by Charlotte Comer ASID RIDPhotography by Stephen Karlisch.White kitchens never seem to go out of style, but there's a fine line

Read More

Should You Fix Up Your House Before Listing Or Sell It As A Fixer Upper

If you're thinking of selling your home, this is probably a question you've been asking yourself - and your real estate agent. There is no hard and fast answer; the route you go will depend on

Read More

Live In Chapel Trail For Less Than 300K

If you are looking to purchase a home in the West Pembroke Pines area you are almost guaranteed to spend over $300K in today's market. Most properties in Pembroke Pines that enter the market sell

Read More

Dont Recarpet Your Home Before Reading This

Getting new carpet can be pricey, but it sure does look great when it's done! If you're getting ready to lay down some new stuff, or at least researching your options, you may have a bit of sticker

Read More